Adventures in mask making
I’ve had quite a few friends ask me about making masks, so am putting together what I have discovered into this one blog post for easy reference. As many of you know, Melbourne is currently in it’s second lockdown period while we attempt to prevent further community spread of covid-19. This time around we’ve been asked to wear masks when we’re in public places where it might be difficult to keep a distance of 1.5m from other people. So those of us who know how to sew have been sewing.
The Victorian government have some mask guidelines. It is acknowledged that reusable masks are a help; they are scientifically shown to reduce the chance of transmitting the virus (mask wearing is more about protecting others than about protecting yourself). We’re not pretending that they’re going to be quite as effective as properly worn and used medical grade masks, but every little bit helps. There’s a good discussion about masks here and here on the Coronacast podcast.
Personally, I don’t like wearing these masks, for a plethora of reasons. But I will wear masks when out, and my whole family have been, because it’s our responsibility to work together as a community. We must do what’s needed for the common good at the moment – to state the obvious, it’s a pandemic!
As you would imagine, a plethora of patterns and tutorials are available for a variety of masks in a variety of styles. I’m not covering everything in this blog post. Google is your friend (other than google that leads you to conspiracy theories or articles that prefer to ignore science in favour of politics). It is clear to me that different people prefer different styles of masks – it’s quite individual and possibly depends on face shape and size. They also have different fastening preferences. You do you. There are three main types of reusable masks:
- Flat with some pleats (like a fabric version of a surgical mask)
- ‘Origami’ style
- Fitted/shaped (I think they’re technically called Olsen masks)
I’ll go through each type with links to patterns that I have tried.
Clare quite likes the flat with pleats style. This tutorial gives you an outline of how to sew them. I found that there was less bulk if I sewed separate casings on to each side rather than turned the sides in to form casings because of the bulk of the pleats.
Clare and I like masks where there is enough fabric to sit flat against our face and nose once we’ve put our glasses on the top of them. They’re loose enough at the sides so that we can breathe relatively easily (fabric masks are not meant to have a tight seal the whole way around; it’s a balance between fit against the face and comfort – which includes breathing, unsurprisingly).
The mask in the photo above didn’t work well for Clare – the elastic is too wide and pulls against her ears. You can see the pleats though. The next style that we tried was a fitted/shaped mask. We tried a few patterns. The Dhurata Davies pattern is very popular on Instagram. It has darts for the nose and the chin. But you can see in the photo below that this one fogged up my glasses straight away.
We had much more success with the Twig and Tale panel mask. This is Dan’s preferred style and pattern.
This one has a pocket in it to add a filter if you’re keen (we’re not adding them at this stage) and has a wire to shape around the nose bridge in the top. I used three plastic coated twist ties together for the wire – I found a heap of them in the bottom of a kitchen drawer. Different people use different types of wires to aid in shaping the mask to their nose bridge. I actually prefer my masks without the wire, but Dan likes it in his.
Other fitted/panel style masks that others have recommended include the Marfy mask, the Mimi G mask, and the Craft Passion mask. Many of these mask patterns have associated YouTube tutorials. The Ann Benson mask also looks interesting, but I haven’t tried it.
My preferred style of mask is the origami type of mask. Actually, the very first mask that I sewed was the Aplat mask!
I then moved on to the Summer Face Mask tutorial, which is on YouTube. This is one that I have used quite extensively.
A similar pattern is the 7 Pine Design origami face mask, and once again there are a plethora of YouTube tutorials for this style.
I also gave this contoured orgami-style variation from the Japanese Sewing Books blog a go, in foiled denim for a bit of farshun.
So, there are some patterns for you to consider. I also experimented a bit with fabrics throughout my mask sewing ‘journey’. I have ended up with a preference for three layers of fabric as a maxium. Maybe something like a twill or a denim or a medium weight quilting cotton for the outer, a lining type fabric or a lightweight knit for a middle layer (you can leave out the middle layer), and something soft and cotton for the inner lining layer (like flannelette or smooth cotton). I find that flannelette is good as it absorbs the moisture from my breath before it has the chance to fog up my glasses.
Then you need to consider how you want to keep the mask on your head. What works best seems to depend on your head size/shape, and your hairstyle! Elastic cord works well for Dan’s masks, but the girls and I prefer ‘t-shirt elastic’. These are strips cut from lengths of cotton/lycra knit about one inch wide, that you then pull and it rolls inwards. These work well for ties around the back of the head and for ear loops (the girls prefer ear loops).
Some other handy links:
How to tie a surgical mask to prevent fogging
No fog mask hack
A simple method to prevent glasses from fogging when wearing a mask
I have my fingers crossed that I never have to sew another mask again. I intellectualised the process in order to make it bearable. There’s no way to deny that we’re in a pandemic when you’re using your favourite hobby to sew masks because of it. Anyway, I hope that this blog post proves useful to some readers. To finish off with a giggle, my family had a few seconds of mask-related fame on breakfast tv this week.
Thanks for your insights! I am trying to gather energy to make another 30 masks for family members heading off to university. Stay safe and healthy!
Thanks for this. I have just come home from a week in the RMH (not somewhere you want to be at the moment! ) and I’m about to tackle mask making. My husband is my guinea pig but, being an engineer, he keeps modifying my pattern. I think I will just commit to the sewing and he can choose the fabric. Llamas for a 60 year old in a Zoom meeting?
Thanks for this, Lara! I haven’t been keen on the pattern I’ve tried so far, so it’s good to see a few alternatives.
This website shows some tests on different fabric types. https://scitechdaily.com/scientists-test-best-fabric-choices-for-making-a-homemade-covid-mask/
Tee shirt fabric (2 layers) performed quite well although 3 layers are usually recommended. If you need the air to coming in around the sides to breath – then the mask is not working. You need air to go through the fabric to filter it.
I found it useful to listen to what Norman Swan said about mask comfort and breathability. Some air going out the sides is okay according to him.
Dr Norman Swan is fantastic. He loves scientific research. I’ve found it impossible to not have some air coming in the sides. But if you can’t breath unless air comes in the sides, the question is, is any air going through the mask at all?
One test I saw said the best fabrics were cotton pillow cases and t-shirt fabric, layered together. https://smartairfilters.com/en/blog/best-materials-make-diy-masks-virus/
There’s been some excellent research done in this area for those who want to get right into the nitty gritty.
After trying several pattern the 7 Pines pattern is my favorite. Thanks for sharing some new to me patterns. I’ve got to make more before school starts. I too hope I never have to sew masks again.
Thankyou for your review. I’ve some new patterns to try. No cases here at the moment, but not holding my breath. I had to add a dart under the chin on the pleated style, so plan on trying shaped styles. I put pipe cleaner across the nose of mine, which helps, but my glasses still fog up. The no fog mask hack works a treat.
Lara, what a great and thorough post on masks. You’ve shown so many great styles, and I’ve loved your opinions on the different styles.
Gotta comment on the tops for you and your adorable girls, though I bet they hate being called “adorable”! The name of the blue that is so close to purple is periwinkle. It can be a brighter periwinkle like the tops you made, or even a soft pastel sort of shade, like a light lavender, but still “blue”. Periwinkle is actually my favorite color! The periwinkle wildflower is a “Great Plains” USA wildflower, now sold in nurseries in the viney form, perfect for cooler weather flower box trailing plants!
Just my opinion, but making the tops somewhat longer in back would create a more even-looking hemline that flares out a bit less.
Thankyou Lara. Your post is timely, very useful and very readable. I have made a few masks, but stopped when I started to get confused about the advice re fabrics – cotton near the face is ok, but what about the non-woven middle layer (?) and waterproof outside layer( if it is waterproof can you breathe through it?) Anyway I think I will follow your advice, and just go on making and try a few other patterns. Best wishes
Thanks for this! Steeling myself to sew a few more masks this weekend. Sewing is normally my escape from the world and it’s surprisingly mentally difficult to turn it into yet more pandemic related activity. Having a variety of patterns seems to help 🙂
Lara, you have gone to so much trouble to put this post together so a huge Thank You. I made heaps too early on. Lets hope we can get through this. I will make some more I guess as this recent surge ramps up. Thanks too for all your other posts I love seeing what you sew and have tried a few myself.
Thanks for the post, I hadn’t seen the origami masks before – they look interesting. I also wear glasses and have found the Dhurata Davies pattern works well for me once I added a nose wire – I can now do Coles in relative comfort even if only about 40% of our suburb seem to be wearing them and we’re surrounded by hotspots.
That’s a particularly useful tip about the T-shirt loops. I have made about 30 masks so far for various people and narrow elastic is in very short supply here in the UK. thanks Lara, the one bonus of sewing masks for a community like ours is that it is a useful thing for all those scraps of leftover material and I do get a kick out of matching lining (jersey or bamboo) with outer (cotton/polycotton/batik)
Thanks for this and all your evidence based (family guinea pig) research. I’m making masks for my students in my classroom for September as in a foods room we are closer than 6ft. I tried the Kleenex glasses hack and it worked really well!
Thanks for this review! I’ve just tried the Aplat mask which you mention and it seems a good one, comfortable to wear and to talk in. For those with glasses or just wanting a close fit across the nose, I’ve found the Pretty Handy Girl mask construction method makes it fast and easy to add a wire. The outer layer is folded twice and stitched over the smaller lining piece. This creates a channel to put the wire in with no extra work other than to stitch across the seam at either end of the wire to keep it in place. The Pretty Handy Girl mask and the Aplat were both quicker projects than others I’ve tried. Much less fiddly!
What I’ve found most useful in deciding what to use and how protective to try to be is the videos here: http://www.fabricpatch.net/face-masks-for-covid-19-relief.htm They’re made by an ex nurse who now owns a sewing shop. She’s done everything from making masks to be worn by nurses in hospital to demonstrating how to use a normal scarf instead of a mask. The sixth video, the one about masks for kids and teenagers, has near the start a simple explanation of what the mask needs to do to protect others (not a lot, it seems) and refers to other steps to take if you want it to protect yourself too.
Really enjoyed this post and many thanks for the links to patterns. Nothing has killed my sewjo quite like making masks!
I’ve tried the Twig and Tale (fitted) and it worked for my daughters, my husband and me, but needed a lot of tweaking. I tried to alter it for my son and just got nowhere. I tried another pattern and had a major meltdown. The summer mask pattern you showed is the one that most suits him and even that required three toiles. It is now the one my husband most likes too. Now I have five different patterns – one for each of us.
I’m another Health Report/Coronacast fan.
Thank you for sharing your experience and insights and pics!! I hate mask wearing too but we do it anyway also.
What a thorough review! I settled early on to the craftpassion model, which fits different size faces well. But now I want to give the origami ones you suggest a try, as they look like they would work well with glasses too. I have been using t-shirt ties too, both the over the ear configuration for easy maneuverability and around the head for better long-term comfort, it’s good to have a choice.
One thing I have been doing is using pink/tan fabric for the inside. It’s helpful to not have to think at all about which side is what, and to be consistent in the wearing. My household got different fabrics for different people too, so small adjustments stay where they’re meant to be. And finally I have been giving people masks made from scraps of what I made for them for a bit of a matchy matchy giggle (the Australian lizards on screaming yellow are having a much-appreciated second life). My scraps are so tame compared to yours though 😁
Some dummy has marked your content as abusive so it can’t be shared on social media! Just letting you know in the hope you can fix it!
Good grief! How can that be fixed?
You should be able to report it to WordPress and they will review the post. Have a look in customer care or whatever
Unfortunately the problem is at the Facebook end of things, so affects all their social media (includes Messenger and Instagram). I have contacted them numerous times asking how the blog violates ‘community standards’ but there is never a response. I don’t think that it is fixable unfortunately!
Oh dear! I wonder if you could republish the post Under a new name to get around it? It’s a great roundup of mask patterns, which is just what we need right now. Good luck!
Hi Lara Thank you for this!! What size of the Summer Face Mask did you use for you and/or Clare? I made a small, but it’s tiny. Maybe it’s for kids? Sizing up… -Lynne (@lynnesews)
Hi Lynne – I’m pretty sure it was the Medium.